Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Game, Set and Match: Weather Underground

If you enjoy watching and comparing the various forecasts issued by local and national weather sources, today made for great entertainment. We love it when forecasters separate from the crowd. It gives us something to watch when someone takes a chance.

We began monitoring the forecasts for today last Friday. It was hard not to miss the fact that Weather Underground BestForecast was out on a limb, five degrees higher than any other weather outlet. Comments to a recent post derided Weather Underground's renegade forecast, pronouncing it to be a "joke." Well, they're certain laughing back at WU's San Francisco headquarters in China Basin after today's high reached exactly what WU forecast last Friday. Well done, gentleman.

Here's how far off (under predicted) the various weather sources were based on today's actual temperature and Friday's forecast high.

Wunderground BestForecast: 95 (exact!)
Weather.com: 89 (-6)
Accuweather.com: 85 (-10)
Weather.gov: 89 (-6)
Wcco: 86 (-9)
Kstp: 85 (-10)
Kmsp: 87 (-8)
Kare: 85 (-10)
Strib: 80 (-15)

It's interesting to note that the best local television forecast was 8 degrees off, yet the national and governmental sources, excluding Accuweather, were within 6 degrees. Not a good showing for the locals.

49 comments:

  1. A snapshot of the forecast does not constitute "monitoring". There is no trend information, no view earlier than Friday. Why not start last Tuesday, 7 days before the event? What about an actual review of the state of the forecasting art? What is the "standard" error for a four-day forecast?

    What do you mean when you say "Not a good showing for the locals"? Is your message that none of the local forecasters equaled Wunderground's single forecast point?

    The shrill whine of this website as it regularly puts forth the least possible effort and then declares that the forecasters failed is tiresome. I had hoped that this blog would fulfill the mission it set for itself and am regularly disappointed. This is the last time I'll come here. I've been fooled too many times. Hopefully the rest of the readers will follow suit.

    --Kevin.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good riddance Kevin,and don't let the backspace button hit you in the ass!!!!This blog follows the MSP forecast point and no others,so when Wunderground temps were compared to the locals forecast at MSP it wasnt even close(how can you not see that).Another question for you is why go beyond 5 days,like you suggested,when most mets can't even nail a forecast 48 hours out.Bill keep it up,I appreciate you and the work of this blog,dont let trolls bother you.

    Looks as though PD takes the cake for biggest miss(15 degrees)that is a big miss.Bill you may want to start monitoring another Tuesday(this time for chilly weather),next Tuesday the 18th,both PD and NWS have a high of 59,where as Wunderground has 68,that variance is too great to overlook.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for the support, Big Daddy. Hard to understand why someone would spend so much time commenting on a site they proclaim to be a waste of their time.

      Delete
  3. So here are the stats through Sept. 11th.

    Our average high temp is 84.3°
    Our average low temp is 59.7°

    This leaves us with a average temp for the month of 72° which is +5.9° above the 30 year average through the first 11 days of the month.

    But what is on the horizon? Another warmer than normal weekend is setting up. After that all bets are off. All of the indices that meteorologist's look at are showing a major cooling trend. The Pacific North American Oscillation (PNA) is showing signs of going strongly positive which means a ridge on the west coast, thus higher than normal temps out there. The Arctic Oscillation (AO) is showing signs of going strongly negative which means cooler air could be released from the arctic and be transported down to us. The North American Oscillation (NAO) is also showing signs of going strongly negative which means blocking over eastern Canada to Greenland, thus slowing down the progression to the east of troughs and ridges.

    So what does that mean? Without any ridges (warmer than normal temps) being able to work into our area, the troughs (cooler than normal temps) will continue to dive into Minnesota without much moisture to work with, keeping the storm track to our south. Because of this I suspect that we will see some much below normal highs next week, after that they will tend to modify. But without much cloud cover I think that over night lows could be lower that what the models are showing.

    So even though we are sitting at +5.9° as I type this, I think this month has a good chance of seeing below normal temps overall. That would break our streak of 15 consecutive months of above normal temps. What do I think of the chances? My head says 50/50, my gut says 60/40 chance of below normal temps for the month.

    So Bill....I really think you have a chance of getting out ahead of the local forecaster's. You should start a new thread...Will September temps go below normal for the first time in 15 months?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I wish that monthly forecasts were made by the various forecasters. It's an interesting question, but I'm not sure how to do a comparative evaluation without many providing formal forecasts.

      It will be interesting to see if the 5.9 variance can be captured and built back into the negative direction. Given the trend of the last many months, it's hard to argue that September will end up below normal, but it's got to happen some day! (or month)

      Delete
    2. Bill: you said:

      "wish that monthly forecasts were made by the various forecasters. It's an interesting question, but I'm not sure how to do a comparative evaluation without many providing formal forecasts."

      You really don't have to do a comparative evaluation, and I know that this is what this site is all about. Just trying to get a discussion going is all. I suspect our local mets will start talking about it soon.

      Delete
  4. Watch out........Monday night or Tuesday night of next week we could be flirting with frost advisories,at least north of metro,let's say Hinckely on north,maybe St.Cloud!

    ReplyDelete
  5. New mexico, California, TCU, Ohio Express, Wake Forest,

    Virginia Technical, Texas Tech, Xavier and El monte all play game titles that will either help solidify their at-large berth/seed or make Selection

    On the more of an restless

    March Madness
    March Madness Live
    March Madness Live Stream
    March Madness Bracket
    March Madness 2017
    March Madness 2017 Live
    NCAA March Madness
    2017 March Madness
    march madness schedule
    march madness schedule 2017

    ReplyDelete
  6. This time, we head to Birmingham, Alabama to check out UFC 10 from July 1996, which brings back the eight-man one-night tournament format. Barely a decade ago, the Ultimate Fighting Championship was looked at as little more than a freak show a human cockfight that drew the attention.
    UFC 210
    UFC 210 Live , UFC 210 Fight Card , UFC 210 Fight , UFC 210 Card , UFC 210 Live Stream , UFC 210 PPV



    UFC 10 Review: Mark Coleman Enters The Octagon For. Joel AbrahamContributor IIIDecember 24, 2010. I am still having nightmares about UFC 10. FS1 presents the Ultimate Fighting Championship's top pound-for-pound fighters across two weeks of prime time action with the UFC 10 Day.
    UFC 210
    UFC 210 Live , UFC 210 Fight Card , UFC 210 Fight , UFC 210 Card , UFC 210 Live Stream , UFC 210 PPV

    ReplyDelete
  7. https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/how-to-watch-canelo-vs-jacobs-full-fight/
    Canelo Alvarez vs. Daniel Jacobs at T-Mobile Arena in Las Vegas, NV - Get Tickets Online. Tickets to Sports,
    Concerts and more online now. 100% Buyer Guaranteed, Secure Checkout. eTickets available. Secure Checkout.
    100% Guarantee. Find Deals. Instant Download & Save. Authentic Tickets
    how to watch canelo vs jacobs full fight
    Canelo Alvarez vs. Daniel Jacobs. Sat. May 4, 2019 2:15 PM - T-Mobile Arena, Las Vegas, NV. NOTE: Prices set by sellers, may be over face-value. Seats
    how to watch canelo vs jacobs full fight
    Get 5% Back - Better Seats - Cheaper Prices - Wide Selection - Upper Level - Ringside. 4.7 Rating - Save Now - 100% Guaranteed Authentic - A+ BBB - Since 1985. All sections available. 5% Back off your order

    ReplyDelete

  8. https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/canelo-alvarez-vs-daniel-jacobs-press-conference/
    Canelo Alvarez vs. Daniel Jacobs at T-Mobile Arena in Las Vegas, NV - Get Tickets Online. Tickets to Sports,
    Concerts and more online now. 100% Buyer Guaranteed, Secure Checkout. eTickets available. Secure Checkout.
    100% Guarantee. Find Deals. Instant Download & Save. Authentic Tickets
    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel-Jacobs Press Conference
    Canelo Alvarez vs. Daniel Jacobs. Sat. May 4, 2019 2:15 PM - T-Mobile Arena, Las Vegas, NV. NOTE: Prices set by sellers, may be over face-value. Seats
    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel-Jacobs Press Conference
    Get 5% Back - Better Seats - Cheaper Prices - Wide Selection - Upper Level - Ringside. 4.7 Rating - Save Now - 100% Guaranteed Authentic - A+ BBB - Since 1985. All sections available. 5% Back off your order

    ReplyDelete
  9. https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/watch-canelo-vs-jacobs-live-boxing-tv-free/
    Canelo Alvarez vs. Daniel Jacobs at T-Mobile Arena in Las Vegas, NV - Get Tickets Online. Tickets to Sports,
    Concerts and more online now. 100% Buyer Guaranteed, Secure Checkout. eTickets available. Secure Checkout.
    100% Guarantee. Find Deals. Instant Download & Save. Authentic Tickets
    Watch Canelo vs Jacobs Live Boxing TV Free
    Canelo Alvarez vs. Daniel Jacobs. Sat. May 4, 2019 2:15 PM - T-Mobile Arena, Las Vegas, NV. NOTE: Prices set by sellers, may be over face-value. Seats
    Watch Canelo vs Jacobs Live Boxing TV Free
    Get 5% Back - Better Seats - Cheaper Prices - Wide Selection - Upper Level - Ringside. 4.7 Rating - Save Now - 100% Guaranteed Authentic - A+ BBB - Since 1985. All sections available. 5% Back off your order

    ReplyDelete
  10. https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/canelo-alvarez-vs-daniel-jacobs-ticket-prices/
    Canelo Alvarez vs. Daniel Jacobs at T-Mobile Arena in Las Vegas, NV - Get Tickets Online. Tickets to Sports,
    Concerts and more online now. 100% Buyer Guaranteed, Secure Checkout. eTickets available. Secure Checkout.
    100% Guarantee. Find Deals. Instant Download & Save. Authentic Tickets
    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs Tickets Prices
    Canelo Alvarez vs. Daniel Jacobs. Sat. May 4, 2019 2:15 PM - T-Mobile Arena, Las Vegas, NV. NOTE: Prices set by sellers, may be over face-value. Seats
    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs Tickets Prices
    Get 5% Back - Better Seats - Cheaper Prices - Wide Selection - Upper Level - Ringside. 4.7 Rating - Save Now - 100% Guaranteed Authentic - A+ BBB - Since 1985. All sections available. 5% Back off your order

    ReplyDelete
  11. https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/canelo-alvarez-vs-daniel-jacobs-fight-card/
    Canelo Alvarez vs. Daniel Jacobs at T-Mobile Arena in Las Vegas, NV - Get Tickets Online. Tickets to Sports,
    Concerts and more online now. 100% Buyer Guaranteed, Secure Checkout. eTickets available. Secure Checkout.
    100% Guarantee. Find Deals. Instant Download & Save. Authentic Tickets
    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs Fight Card
    Canelo Alvarez vs. Daniel Jacobs. Sat. May 4, 2019 2:15 PM - T-Mobile Arena, Las Vegas, NV. NOTE: Prices set by sellers, may be over face-value. Seats
    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs Fight Card
    Get 5% Back - Better Seats - Cheaper Prices - Wide Selection - Upper Level - Ringside. 4.7 Rating - Save Now - 100% Guaranteed Authentic - A+ BBB - Since 1985. All sections available. 5% Back off your order

    ReplyDelete

  12. https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/canelo-alvarez-vs-daniel-jacobs-ppv/
    Canelo Alvarez vs. Daniel Jacobs at T-Mobile Arena in Las Vegas, NV - Get Tickets Online. Tickets to Sports,
    Concerts and more online now. 100% Buyer Guaranteed, Secure Checkout. eTickets available. Secure Checkout.
    100% Guarantee. Find Deals. Instant Download & Save. Authentic Tickets
    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs PPV
    Canelo Alvarez vs. Daniel Jacobs. Sat. May 4, 2019 2:15 PM - T-Mobile Arena, Las Vegas, NV. NOTE: Prices set by sellers, may be over face-value. Seats
    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs PPV
    Get 5% Back - Better Seats - Cheaper Prices - Wide Selection - Upper Level - Ringside. 4.7 Rating - Save Now - 100% Guaranteed Authentic - A+ BBB - Since 1985. All sections available. 5% Back off your order

    ReplyDelete
  13. https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/watch-canelo-vs-jacobs-full-fight-card/
    Canelo Alvarez vs. Daniel Jacobs at T-Mobile Arena in Las Vegas, NV - Get Tickets Online. Tickets to Sports,
    Concerts and more online now. 100% Buyer Guaranteed, Secure Checkout. eTickets available. Secure Checkout.
    100% Guarantee. Find Deals. Instant Download & Save. Authentic Tickets
    Watch Canelo vs Jacobs Full Fight Card
    Canelo Alvarez vs. Daniel Jacobs. Sat. May 4, 2019 2:15 PM - T-Mobile Arena, Las Vegas, NV. NOTE: Prices set by sellers, may be over face-value. Seats
    Watch Canelo vs Jacobs Full Fight Card
    Get 5% Back - Better Seats - Cheaper Prices - Wide Selection - Upper Level - Ringside. 4.7 Rating - Save Now - 100% Guaranteed Authentic - A+ BBB - Since 1985. All sections available. 5% Back off your order

    ReplyDelete
  14. https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/canelo-alvarez-vs-daniel-jacobs-undercard/
    Canelo Alvarez vs. Daniel Jacobs at T-Mobile Arena in Las Vegas, NV - Get Tickets Online. Tickets to Sports,
    Concerts and more online now. 100% Buyer Guaranteed, Secure Checkout. eTickets available. Secure Checkout.
    100% Guarantee. Find Deals. Instant Download & Save. Authentic Tickets
    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs Undercard
    Canelo Alvarez vs. Daniel Jacobs. Sat. May 4, 2019 2:15 PM - T-Mobile Arena, Las Vegas, NV. NOTE: Prices set by sellers, may be over face-value. Seats
    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs Undercard
    Get 5% Back - Better Seats - Cheaper Prices - Wide Selection - Upper Level - Ringside. 4.7 Rating - Save Now - 100% Guaranteed Authentic - A+ BBB - Since 1985. All sections available. 5% Back off your order

    ReplyDelete
  15. https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/canelo-alvarez-vs-daniel-jacobs-tickets/
    Canelo Alvarez vs. Daniel Jacobs at T-Mobile Arena in Las Vegas, NV - Get Tickets Online. Tickets to Sports,
    Concerts and more online now. 100% Buyer Guaranteed, Secure Checkout. eTickets available. Secure Checkout.
    100% Guarantee. Find Deals. Instant Download & Save. Authentic Tickets
    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs Tickets
    Canelo Alvarez vs. Daniel Jacobs. Sat. May 4, 2019 2:15 PM - T-Mobile Arena, Las Vegas, NV. NOTE: Prices set by sellers, may be over face-value. Seats
    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs Tickets
    Get 5% Back - Better Seats - Cheaper Prices - Wide Selection - Upper Level - Ringside. 4.7 Rating - Save Now - 100% Guaranteed Authentic - A+ BBB - Since 1985. All sections available. 5% Back off your order

    ReplyDelete
  16. It's almost time for Canelo to meet the Golden Child. Saul Alvarez's WBA and WBC middleweight titles are on the line against Daniel Jacobs' IBF

    championsip. That's right it's a title unification fight and we'll tell you how to get a Canelo Alvarez vs Jacobs live stream, no matter where on

    Earth you are.

    https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/how-to-watch-canelo-alvarez-vsdaniel-jacobs/

    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs
    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs Live

    ReplyDelete
  17. It's almost time for Canelo to meet the Golden Child. Saul Alvarez's WBA and WBC middleweight titles are on the line against Daniel Jacobs' IBF

    championsip. That's right it's a title unification fight and we'll tell you how to get a Canelo Alvarez vs Jacobs live stream, no matter where on

    Earth you are.

    https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/canelo-vs-jacobs-ppv-full-fight/

    Canelo vs Jacobs
    Canelo vs Jacobs Live

    ReplyDelete
  18. It's almost time for Canelo to meet the Golden Child. Saul Alvarez's WBA and WBC middleweight titles are on the line against Daniel Jacobs' IBF

    championsip. That's right it's a title unification fight and we'll tell you how to get a Canelo Alvarez vs Jacobs live stream, no matter where on

    Earth you are.

    https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/canelo-vs-jacobs-live-boxing-fight/
    Canelo vs Jacobs
    Canelo vs Jacobs Live

    ReplyDelete
  19. It's almost time for Canelo to meet the Golden Child. Saul Alvarez's WBA and WBC middleweight titles are on the line against Daniel Jacobs' IBF

    championsip. That's right it's a title unification fight and we'll tell you how to get a Canelo Alvarez vs Jacobs live stream, no matter where on

    Earth you are.


    https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/canelo-vs-jacobs-live-boxing-in-hd-tv/

    Canelo vs Jacobs
    Canelo vs Jacobs Live

    ReplyDelete
  20. It's almost time for Canelo to meet the Golden Child. Saul Alvarez's WBA and WBC middleweight titles are on the line against Daniel Jacobs' IBF

    championsip. That's right it's a title unification fight and we'll tell you how to get a Canelo Alvarez vs Jacobs live stream, no matter where on

    Earth you are.

    https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/canelo-vs-jacobs-live-boxing-full-fight-card/

    Canelo vs Jacobs
    Canelo vs Jacobs Live

    ReplyDelete
  21. It's almost time for Canelo to meet the Golden Child. Saul Alvarez's WBA and WBC middleweight titles are on the line against Daniel Jacobs' IBF

    championsip. That's right it's a title unification fight and we'll tell you how to get a Canelo Alvarez vs Jacobs live stream, no matter where on

    Earth you are.


    https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/canelo-alvarez-vs-danny-jacobs-live-telecast/

    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs
    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs Live

    ReplyDelete
  22. It's almost time for Canelo to meet the Golden Child. Saul Alvarez's WBA and WBC middleweight titles are on the line against Daniel Jacobs' IBF

    championsip. That's right it's a title unification fight and we'll tell you how to get a Canelo Alvarez vs Jacobs live stream, no matter where on

    Earth you are.

    https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/watch-canelo-alvarez-vs-danny-jacobs-live-boxing-tv-free/

    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs
    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs Live

    ReplyDelete
  23. It's almost time for Canelo to meet the Golden Child. Saul Alvarez's WBA and WBC middleweight titles are on the line against Daniel Jacobs' IBF

    championsip. That's right it's a title unification fight and we'll tell you how to get a Canelo Alvarez vs Jacobs live stream, no matter where on

    Earth you are.

    https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/watch-canelo-alvarez-vs-danny-jacobs-live-boxing-full-fight/

    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs
    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs Live

    ReplyDelete
  24. Saturday night, it’s the boxing mega-fight the hardcore fans have been craving: Canelo Alvarez (51-1-1; 34 KO) vs. Gennady Golovkin (37-0; 33 KO). Winner establishes his dominance as the undisputed king of the 160 pound Middleweight division, and it will be hard pressed to keep him out of one of the very topmost spots in pound for pound rankings.
    how to watch canelo alvarez vs jacobs boxing betting

    ReplyDelete
  25. The fight will air live on PPV this Saturday, September 16 with a fight time of 8:00 p.m. ET. for the PPV card. Canelo vs. GGG headlines a four fight PPV card that also includes Joseph Diaz, Jr. among others.
    canelo alvarez vs jacobs fight time

    ReplyDelete
  26. Canelo Alvarez has been hyped as the next big thing for Mexican boxing, and he has proven that he deserves that hype.
    canelo alvarez vs jacobs event time

    ReplyDelete
  27. He started to really break out in the US in 2012, earning himself a shot at Floyd Mayweather in 2013. He comes in off an absolutely dreadful fight against Julio Cesar Chavez, Jr. Canelo remains a big fan favorite
    jacobs vs alvarez boxing buy las vegas tickets

    ReplyDelete
  28. He won the true Middleweight title in 2015 from Miguel Cotto, but his reign has cost him many fans, as it’s been marked largely by him fighting at strange catchweights and refusing to fight Golovkin.
    when is canelo alvarez's next fight date time price

    ReplyDelete
  29. He comes in off an absolutely dreadful fight against Julio Cesar Chavez, Jr. Canelo remains a big fan favorite for his Mexican fans,
    how to watch canelo alvarez vsdaniel jacobs live online

    ReplyDelete
  30. Gennady Golovkin is an insanely powerful puncher - undefeated, and with only 4 of his 37 opponents ever making the final bell. He has been riding an amazing 9 year streak of KOs,
    canelo alvarez vs daniel jacobs predictions odds preview

    ReplyDelete

  31. Golovkin’s power is always the deciding factor in his fights - always. He’s the kind of puncher that can change things instantly.
    canelo alvarez vs danny jacobs tickets in las vegas

    ReplyDelete

  32. THE NATIONAL ACADEMYOF TELEVISION ARTS & SCIENCESANNOUNCES PRESENTERS FORTHE 46th ANNUAL DAYTIME EMMY® AWARDS Chef
    Jacques Pepin and Judge Judy Sheindlin to be Honored with Lifetime Achievement Awards Pasadena, CA – April 29th, 2019 –The National
    Academy of Television Arts & Sciences (NATAS) today announced the presenters for both the 46th Annual Daytime Creative Arts…
    Daytime Creative Arts Emmy® Daytime Emmy Awards 2019 Live Stream The Insider / April 16,
    2019 Daytime Emmy® Awards Hosts Announced MARIO LOPEZ & SHERYL UNDERWOOD ANNOUNCED AS HOSTS FOR THE 46th ANNUAL DAYTIME EMMY® AWARDS AND DAVID OSMOND
    AS HOST FOR THE CREATIVE ARTS AWARDS WITH CAROLYN HENNESY HOSTING THE RED CARPET LIVE AND POST SHOW INTERVIEWS WITH THE WINNERS LOS ANGELES, CA –
    April 16, 2019 – Announced today on the CBS Daytime program.

    ReplyDelete